Quick & Easy Cheesy Polenta Recipe (Only 25 Minutes!) (2024)

Polenta is a delicious, easy-to-prepare corn dish, similar to grits. I love it for its quick prep time and creamy goodness. Try this quick and cheesy polenta recipe for a great dinner.

I first heard about polenta in the 90s when I worked at a fancy-schmancy restaurant in Santa Barbara. There they served it sliced and grilled. I tried it, and didn’t care for it.

But, I really wanted to like it.

After giving it the good old college try a few years ago, I’m a fan. In a big way. Here’s why:

Why I love polenta

• Polenta is super versatile.

According to the New Food Lover’s Companion,

A staple of northern Italy, polenta is a mush made from cornmeal. It can be eaten hot with a little butter or cooled until firm, cut into squares and fried. Polenta is sometimes mixed with cheese such as Parmesan or Gorgonzola. It can be served as a first course or side dish and makes hearty breakfast fare.

I agree on all points. I’ve served it as a gluten-free alternative to pasta, piling it high with meatballs, meat sauce, or other Italian-style meats. I’ve enjoyed it as a side dish to sausage and greens. I’ve made polenta “pizzas”, by slicing the chilled leftover polenta — it firms up when cool — and topping it with sauce and cheese. I’ve reheated leftovers and topped it with a fried egg. Super good!

• Polenta is quick and easy to make.

Polenta cooks up in less than half an hour, making it a quick fix base to many a meal. Just another delicious, quick dinner idea!

I vary the seasonings and the liquids I use to prepare it, based on what I have on hand. The recipe below is one of my favorites!

Is polenta gluten free?

Polenta is made of corn which is naturally gluten-free. However, keep in mind that corn is a grain that often becomes cross-contaminated with wheat and other gluten-containing grains.

Be sure to buy gluten-free polenta to ensure yours is without gluten.

What is polenta?

Polenta is essentially a cooked Italian porridge. Although it can be made with different grains, in general it’s made with cornmeal.

Be sure to use a bag of cornemal specifically labeled as “polenta” or “corn grits. It’s a coarser in texture than regular bag of cornmeal.

Polenta vs. Grits

Although both a c orn porridge they do have some signficant differences. Polenta is an Italian dish, where grits is an American dish that hails from the South. Both are made from dried corn. But polenta is coarser in texture.

Grits is also usually made from hominy, a version of dried corn that has undergone under a special chemical process. You can get the hominy 101 here from Spruce Eats. It’s the same process to make masa flour that’s used to make hHomemade corn tortillas.

Ingredients to make cheesy polenta

• Chicken stock – Store-bought or make your own like this my homemade Chicken Stock in the Slow Cooker.
• Milk – Low-fat or whole would work fine. I haven’t tried this with any dairy-free milk but I think it would work fine.
• Seasoning – Just some simple salt and pepper is all you need.
• Polenta – Be sure to use cornmeal bag labeled with “polenta” or “corn grits”
• Parmesan cheese – Shredded parmesan cheese, but asiago or romano works as well.

How to make polenta

• Combine broth, milk, and salt. In a medium saucepan over medium-high heat, whisk together the broth, milk, and salt. Bring to a low boil.

• Add polenta. Stir in the polenta and reduce the heat to simmer. Cook, stirring, for 15 to 20 minutes, until the mixture is thick and creamy. Add more water if necessary to prevent sticking.

• Add butter and cheese. Stir in the butter and add the cheese in small amounts, stirring to incorporate well. Season to taste with pepper and serve.

How to reheat leftover polenta

If you have leftovers, you can store it in a closed container for up to 4 days. It will probably thicken, so just simply warm it up on the stovetop with a little bit more milk to thin it out again and get it back to a creamy consistency.

What do I serve with polenta?

This cheesy polenta is delicious with some simple roasted vegetables, sauteed mushrooms on top. I also love serving this instead of pasta. It works as a beautiful base like my Ragu with Sausage and Onions, easy vegetable bolognese or spicy turkey and sausage bolognese

Or try it with aEasy Mediterranean Grilled Steak,Baked Salmon in Foil, or with my easy grilled Shrimp on the Barbie .

If you prepare this recipe, be sure to share a picture on social media and hashtag it #GOODCHEAPEATS. I can't wait to see what you cook up!

Be sure to check out all the posts in the series: Quick Dinner Ideas.